Stand in a garden centre and the two spades can look almost identical. But a border spade and a digging spade are designed for genuinely different work, and buying the wrong one is a common — and frustrating — mistake. The short answer: a digging spade is your main, do-everything tool, and a border spade is a lighter, more precise second spade for working among plants.
The Key Differences
| Digging Spade | Border Spade | |
|---|---|---|
| Blade size | Larger (≈28 × 19 cm) | Smaller (≈23 × 14 cm) |
| Weight | Heavier — more momentum | Lighter — easier to handle |
| Handle length | Longer — more leverage | Shorter — more control |
| Best soil | Heavy, compacted, clay | Light, established beds |
| Main use | Breaking ground, turning soil | Planting among plants, edging |
| Tight spaces | Awkward | Excellent |
| Best for | Your main, do-everything spade | A precise second spade |
When to Use a Digging Spade
The digging spade is the workhorse. Its larger, heavier blade gives you the momentum to break new ground, cut through roots and turf, and turn over heavy or clay soil. The longer handle provides the leverage you need for serious digging. If you are creating a new bed, planting a shrub or tree, or doing any real soil work, this is the spade you want. For most gardeners, it should be the first — and often only — spade they buy.
When to Use a Border Spade
The border spade trades power for precision. Its smaller blade and shorter handle let you work in tight spaces — among established perennials, in raised beds, or close to delicate plants — without disturbing everything around it. It is lighter and less tiring for extended planting sessions, and it makes beautifully clean edges. Many experienced gardeners own both: a digging spade for the heavy work and a border spade for the fine work.
Which Should You Buy First?
Buy a digging spade first. It is the more versatile tool and will handle the great majority of jobs in any garden. Add a border spade later if you find yourself frequently working in confined spaces or among established plants. Whichever you choose, look for a stainless steel blade and a solid-socket handle joint — the marks of a spade that will last.
Ready to Choose?
See our best digging spade picks
We compared the best garden spades across every budget — from value Spear & Jackson workhorses to a premium stainless Draper.
Read the spade buyer's guideFrequently Asked Questions
Should a beginner buy a border spade or a digging spade?
A digging spade. It is the more versatile of the two and covers the widest range of tasks — breaking ground, turning soil, digging planting holes and edging. A border spade is best thought of as a useful second spade once you have your main one.
Does Monty Don use a border spade or a digging spade?
For general work Monty Don reaches for a full digging spade, which suits the heavy soil work at Longmeadow. A border spade comes into its own for delicate planting among established perennials, where a full-size blade would be too clumsy.
Can a border spade replace a digging spade?
Not entirely. A border spade is lighter and lacks the blade size and leverage to break compacted or clay soil efficiently. If you can only own one spade, choose a digging spade. If you garden mainly in raised beds or very light soil, a border spade may be all you need.